Marcel in Philosophical Practice: a proposal

How can we use the ideas of a philosopher as a starting point for our own thoughts? In the spirit of philosophical practice I am sharing here some personal thoughts that this text of Gabriel Marcel provoked in me.

“We must therefore focus on the condition of a person who isn’t fully identified with his actual surroundings. Some coincidence has exiled him to where he is now, and his place is his place only by chance. In the current conditions to which he must submit, this real place can only be seen as a “beyond,” as the home of home-sickness.”

Some coincidence has thrown me to where I came to this world, out of place. Unwanted by my actual surroundings. I realize I must fight for making this world into a better place. But can´t we leave things as they are? What if most of the other people are comfortable with life as it is – and it is just me who do not fit in? I check and I realize that this is mostly not the case. Unfairness and even violence is haunting our lives and that of people we share our lives with. Most grown-ups have learned to just look away. I make a promise: I will not learn to look away. I will keep alive the home that is “beyond”.

Are these thoughts and yearnings only psychological mechanisms that result from certain experiences in a far away past? But this would not explain anything. As Nicolai Hartmann tells us: our thoughts build upon a physical and a biological level, but these levels do not explain the contents of our thoughts. In this sense saying that our thoughts are psychologically conditioned (in the sense “psychological” is understood generally) does not tell us anything at all about their contents, since everything is somehow psychologically conditioned.

“Our experience of depth is connected to the feeling that a promise is being made, but that we can grasp only a glimpse of the fulfillment of that promise.” (Gabriel Marcel)

So a promise has been made. I couldn´t exactly express in words what this promise consists in. Maybe I do not need to keep it. Maybe I can not keep it. I promise to help here and work there to make this world a better place. But it is not possible. If I work here, I am neglecting people and work there. If I work there I neglect people and work here. What if “beyond” is not better than here and now? What if there is no such thing as “better”? But then again, I have had the experience of grasping a glimpse of the fulfillment of my promise. This glimpse makes it worth for me to get up in the morning and continue, working – and wondering if I will ever return “home”.

(The quotes from Gabriel Marcel are from the text published in Agora -Topics Page - January 2017)



No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Sunday, 26 March 2017

Captcha Image


Carmen Zavala
26 March 2017
Sophia is sitting in the kitchen preparing a cup of coffee after work. Today again she talked to her friend Miranda. Usually they just worked and worked together day after day and they seldom talked. ...
Ran Lahav
24 March 2017
Chapter 3: MIRANDA DECIDES TO CHANGE In the morning, after breakfast, Miranda sits in her armchair, holding a page in her hand. This is what Linda, the philosophical facilitator, had asked them to do...
Ran Lahav
21 March 2017
For me, philosophy is not about discovering THE TRUTH. Philosophy is about giving voice to the many different voices of life and reality. So last night I was delighted to find the following passage in...
Ran Lahav
18 March 2017
It’s the second weekly meeting of the Philosophical Trio, and Miranda is glad to see again her two new companions. Linda, the philosopher and facilitator, invites David and Miranda to share their expe...
Ran Lahav
10 March 2017
Miranda is sitting alone in her room, holding the philosophical text which her philosophical practitioner had given her. Today, like always, she is extremely busy – work, family, cleaning, buying – bu...
Carmen Zavala
06 March 2017
How can we use the ideas of a philosopher as a starting point for our own thoughts? In the spirit of philosophical practice I am sharing here some personal thoughts that this text of Gabriel Marcel pr...
Ran Lahav
03 March 2017
I look at Agora’s “Topics” section – it has so many beautiful philosophical texts from 2500 years of Western philosophy. I go through the monthly pages, month by month, and I see texts by famous philo...
Carmen Zavala
06 February 2017
Is it possible that also our feeling of what is right and wrong is part of our animality? In this sense our sense of morality is not learned by culture nor reason, but it comes from the depth of our b...
Stefano Zampieri
09 January 2017
L’esibizionismo del nostro tempo è soltanto una pallida imitazione, una deformazione, una perversione della naturale condizione esposta dell’uomo. La messa in scena dell’intimità nel grande spettacolo...
Ran Lahav
04 January 2017
Throughout history, many important Western philosophers discussed how philosophy can help transform our lives. Plato, Marcus Aurelius, Spinoza, Rousseau, Nietzsche, Bergson, and many many others – the...
Ran Lahav
31 December 2016
In my book Handbook of Philosophical Companionships (2016), I say: “We contemplate because we treasure profound ideas and profound understandings in togetherness. We cherish the profound, just as in ...
Stefano Zampieri
31 December 2016
Sei esposto Nasci nello sguardo di tua madre, sei esposto al suo affetto, sei nei suoi occhi fin dal primo istante di vita, fin dal primo respiro. Ecco, da questo momento, dal momento in cui nasc...
Albert Hoffmann
28 December 2016
​Sometimes you have to do it upside down, to do it right: navigating towards 2017......
Carmen Zavala
26 December 2016
Blaise Pascal decía que el exceso de virtud es dañino para el hombre. En relación a esta idea de Pascal, a modo de broma, en la foto de la izquierda uno de estos trabajadores que descansa plácidamente...
Ran Lahav
25 December 2016
We often say: "This is a profound idea," or "She was lost in deep thoughts," or "It touched me deeply," or "He is a profound person," or "She had a deep spiritual experience," or "He is deeply attac...